bamama is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies (2023 Guide)

Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies (2023 Guide)

A pacifier is a very important tool, and it should be one of the diaper bag essentials, allowing you to easily access them as it is something included in what to pack in a diaper bag for a hospital.

As a mom who cherishes her role, I understand the importance of finding the perfect pacifier to provide comfort and support for our little ones.

In this guide, I’ll take you on a journey to explore the world of pacifiers for breastfed babies together. Join me as I share personal experiences and review the best pacifiers

EDITOR’S CHOICE

Dr. Brown’s Pacifier Advantage

PREMIUM CHOICE

Philips Avent 6-18m Ultra Air Baby Pacifier

BUDGET CHOICE

Combi Teteo Pacifier Smile

The 5 Best Pacifiers for Breastfeeding Babies

I’m thrilled to present my top picks for the five best pacifiers that cater specifically to the needs of breastfeeding babies.

1. Dr. Brown’s Pacifier Advantage – Editor’s Choice

Dr. Brown's Pacifier Advantage

Features:

  • Size and Shape: Features a fully symmetrical shape with a reversible bulb
  • Materials Used: Made from soft and tender silicone material
  • Best for: Recommended for babies from 0-6 months

I have to say, Dr. Brown’s Pacifier Advantage is hands down one of the best overall pacifiers for breastfeeding babies on the market. 

It truly supports the breastfeeding journey in every way possible. The fully symmetrical shape with a reversible bulb ensures a perfect fit for my baby’s mouth, regardless of position. 

The soft silicone material feels so tender and comfortable. I love how the rounded nipple shape closely resembles a mother’s breast, reducing any nipple confusion.

I also noticed how my babies enjoyed using this pacifier! Plus, the unique guard design grows with them, ensuring the perfect fit for their mouth and face. 

PROS

  • Fully symmetrical shape with a reversible bulb allows for a perfect fit, accommodating various mouth positions.
  • Made from soft silicone material, providing comfort for the baby’s delicate skin
  • Rounded nipple shape closely imitates a mother’s breast, making it easier for breastfed babies to switch

CONS

  • May not be suitable for older babies or toddlers

2. Philips Avent 6-18m Ultra Air Baby Pacifier – Premium Choice

Philips Avent 6-18m Ultra Air Baby Pacifier

Features:

  • Size and Shape: Designed for babies aged 6-18 months with a larger shield and nipple.
  • Materials Used: Made from high-quality, BPA-free silicone.
  • Best for: Recommended for babies between 6 to 18 months old.

The Philips Avent 6-18m Ultra Air Baby Pacifier has been a game-changer for me and my breastfeeding journey. 

Its innovative design combines exceptional comfort with impressive airflow, making it one of the best premium pacifiers for breastfed babies. 

The lightweight shield and open-air holes have greatly reduced skin irritation and allow for better airflow around my baby’s mouth, reducing the risk of moisture buildup. 

The orthodontic shape resembles a mother’s nipple, helping my little one easily transition between breast and pacifier.

PROS

  • The open-air holes in the shield promote airflow
  • Shape mimics natural shape of mother’s nipple
  • Its high-quality material ensures durability and safety for the baby

CONS

  • Limited design options

3. Combi Teteo Pacifier Smile – Budget Choice

Combi Teteo Pacifier Smile

Features:

  • Size and Shape: It features a thin neck design that considers babies’ incisors or front teeth, promoting proper oral development.
  • Materials Used: Made with soft and gentle materials, providing the right elasticity for chewing and tongue movement.
  • Best for: Designed for babies aged 8 to 18 months.

The Combi Teteo Pacifier Smile is truly one of the best budget pacifiers for breastfed babies out there.

Inspired by studies on the oral cavities of babies aged 8 to 18 months, this bright-colored pacifier boasts some remarkable features. 

The thin neck design considers the front teeth, ensuring proper development. The softness of the nipple provides excellent elasticity for chewing and tongue movement.

My baby has never enjoyed a pacifier as much as this one! It also helps that the removable cap makes cleaning a breeze. This pacifier is a definite winner for my breastfed baby!

PROS

  • Thin neck design and arc-shaped design promote proper oral development in babies
  • Soft materials provide proper chewing and tongue movement elasticity
  • Perfect budget pacifier for when you want to see if your baby will accept pacifiers or not

CONS

  • May not be suitable for younger or older infants

4. Chicco Physio Soft Silicon Soother Baby Pacifier

Chicco Physio Soft Silicon Soother Baby Pacifier

Features:

  • Size and Shape: A specially designed shape to provide comfort and support to babies.
  • Materials Used: Made of 100% silicone
  • Best for: Ideal for newborns and young babies from 0 to 6 months.

When finding a pacifier for my newborn, the Chicco Physio Soft Silicon Soother Baby Pacifier is one of the best options. 

I’ve noticed that this pacifier has that special “mum effect” thanks to its exclusive teat finish. It allows my baby’s lips to rest comfortably. 

The design also prioritizes air circulation, reducing the risk of skin irritation and providing a healthy and soothing experience.

I love that this pacifier is made in Italy and crafted from 100% silicone. It’s velvety soft, and gentle, making it perfect for my newborn’s delicate needs. 

PROS

  • Ensures comfort for babies.
  • Promotes air circulation.

CONS

  • May not be suitable for older infants or toddlers.
  • May have limited design options compared to other brands.

5. The First Years GumDrop Baby Pacifier

The First Years GumDrop Baby Pacifier

Features:

  • Size and Shape: It has a distinctive contour shape that stays clear of the infant’s nose.
  • Materials Used: It is made from BPA-free and latex-free silicone
  • Best for: It is suitable for newborns and infants between 0 to 3 months

The First Years GumDrop Baby Pacifier is an excellent choice for a safe and comfortable dummy.

The performance of this pacifier is remarkable. It seamlessly works with most pacifier attachers. The lightweight design makes it easy for my baby to handle and carry around.

One of the reasons I chose this pacifier is because most hospitals trust it. Its distinctive contour shape ensures it stays clear of my baby’s nose. 

Plus, it’s a one-piece BPA-free dummy made from latex-free silicone, giving me peace of mind. I highly recommend this pacifier for its quality and safety features.

PROS

  • Safe and comfortable for newborns
  • Works with most pacifier attachers and is lightweight for easy handling.

CONS

  • Unique contour shape of the pacifier uncomfortable for their baby’s mouth.

When Should You Introduce Your Baby to Pacifiers?

When Should You Introduce Your Baby to Pacifiers?

Knowing when to introduce pacifiers to your baby can vary based on individual preferences and needs. 

It is generally recommended to wait until breastfeeding is well-established, usually around 3-4 weeks, to prevent nipple confusion. 

However, consult with your pediatrician. Additionally, if your baby shows signs of sucking, such as seeking comfort or self-soothing, it may be appropriate to introduce a pacifier earlier. 

Remember to prioritize your baby’s cues and consider their unique development and feeding journey.

Pacifier Benefits

Pacifier Benefits

Pacifiers offer a range of benefits for both babies and parents. These small, nipple-shaped devices can provide infants with comfort, relaxation, and a sense of security. 

Along with soothing a baby, pacifiers can help promote better sleep and provide a healthy outlet for a baby’s natural sucking instincts.

Pacifiers can offer several benefits for babies, including:

  • Soothing and Comfort: Pacifiers can help calm and soothe babies, providing a sense of comfort and security.
  • Sleep Aid: Pacifiers can assist in promoting better sleep for babies. Sucking can help them relax and fall asleep faster, potentially reducing nighttime awakenings.
  • Nipple Substitution: Pacifiers can satisfy a baby’s instinct to suck. This can be helpful for parents by offering an alternative to frequent breastfeeding or bottle-feeding.
  • Pain Relief: Pacifiers can temporarily relieve discomfort associated with teething by providing a gentle distraction and something safe to chew on.
  • Supports Breastfeeding: Using pacifiers can complement breastfeeding by satisfying a baby’s sucking needs while not interfering with breastfeeding routines.
  • Provides a Distraction: Pacifiers can be useful during travel, doctor visits, or other situations that may cause anxiety or stress for the baby.
  • Promotes Self-soothing: Pacifiers can help babies develop self-soothing skills, allowing them to learn to manage their emotions and calm themselves down.
  • Reduces Thumb-sucking: Pacifiers are preferable to thumb-sucking, as it is easier to wean a baby off a pacifier than break a thumb-sucking habit.
  • Provides Comfort during Weaning: Pacifiers can offer comfort and support during the weaning process, helping babies transition away from breastfeeding or bottle feeding.

Remember, while pacifiers can have benefits, it’s important to consider individual preferences and needs. Always consult with your pediatrician for personalized advice and guidance.

Pacifier Do’s and Don’ts

Pacifier Do’s and Don’ts

Regarding pacifier use, following certain dos and don’ts ensures safe and beneficial usage for your baby’s comfort and oral health.

Do’s

  • Wait until breastfeeding is well-established before introducing a pacifier, usually around 3-4 weeks.
  • Regularly clean and sanitize the pacifier using warm water and mild soap. Sterilize it regularly to maintain hygiene.
  • Select one suitable for your baby’s age to ensure proper fit and safety.
  • Regularly inspect the pacifier for any signs of damage, such as cracks or loose parts, and replace it if necessary.
  • Use the pacifier to provide comfort and soothe your baby when needed, but avoid prolonged or constant pacifier use to prevent dependency.

Don’ts

  • If your baby shows resistance or dislikes using a pacifier, don’t force them to use it. Respect their preferences.
  • Never attach a pacifier around your baby’s neck to their clothing, as it poses a strangulation risk.
  • Avoid dipping the pacifier in honey, sugar, or other sweet substances, as it can lead to tooth decay.
  • Discard any pacifier with cracks, tears, or other signs of damage, as it may pose a choking hazard.
  • You should remove the pacifier when the baby is sleeping, as it can increase the risk of pacifier teeth.

How to Find the Best Pacifier for Breastfeeding Babies

How to Find the Best Pacifier for Breastfeeding Babies

Finding the best pacifier for breastfeeding babies is essential for providing comfort and support during their early stages. 

Here, I will share valuable insights and tips to help you navigate the market and choose the perfect pacifier that complements your breastfeeding journey.

Dishwasher Safe

When choosing a pacifier for your breastfed baby, one important tip is whether the pacifier is dishwasher safe. 

The dishwasher-safe feature can greatly simplify your cleaning routine and ensure proper hygiene for your little one’s pacifier.

Opting for a dishwasher-safe pacifier means you can conveniently sanitize it with other baby items, saving you time and effort. 

It eliminates the need for separate hand washing or boiling, which can be cumbersome, especially when you have a busy schedule caring for your baby.

Dishwasher-safe pacifiers are typically made of materials that can withstand high temperatures and the dishwasher’s cleaning cycle. 

They are designed to withstand repeated washes without compromising their quality or durability.

However, it is essential to check the manufacturer’s instructions and guidelines regarding dishwasher use, as some pacifiers may have specific recommendations for optimal cleaning. 

Material

When selecting a pacifier for your breastfed baby, paying attention to the material is crucial. Opt for pacifiers made from safe and non-toxic materials, such as BPA-free silicone.

Silicone pacifiers are popular because they are soft, durable, and easy to clean. They are also less likely to retain odors or develop mold. 

On the other hand, natural rubber pacifiers are made from plant-based materials and provide a more eco-friendly option.

It’s important to avoid pacifiers with harmful chemicals. Look for products labeled as free from BPA, phthalates, PVC, and other harmful substances.

Right Size

The right pacifier size is essential when choosing one for your breastfed baby. It’s important to consider the nipple and shield sizes to ensure a proper fit.

For newborns and younger babies, a smaller nipple size is typically recommended. This allows for a better latch and mimics the size of a mother’s breast. 

As your baby grows, you may need to transition to a larger nipple size to accommodate their developing mouth.

The shield size is equally important as it should be proportionate to your baby’s face and provide enough ventilation. 

A too-large shield may cause discomfort or make it difficult for your baby to hold the pacifier in their mouth.

Remember that each baby is different, so finding the right size that suits your little one may take trial and error. 

Pay attention to your baby’s cues and ensure that the pacifier is neither too big nor too small for their mouth.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

In this FAQ section, find answers to common questions about pacifiers and their suitability for breastfed babies.

Should Breastfed Babies Use Pacifiers?

Yes, breastfed babies can use pacifiers, but it’s recommended to introduce them after breastfeeding is well established, usually around 3-4 weeks, to avoid nipple confusion.

When Can Breastfed Babies Use a Pacifier?

Breastfed babies can start using pacifiers once breastfeeding is established, usually around 3-4 weeks.

When Should Babies Stop Using a Pacifier?

Babies can stop using a pacifier when they reach around 6-12 months of age or when they naturally start showing signs of self-soothing without it. 

However, the exact time when to get rid of the pacifier depends on your baby’s progress and personal preferences.

Are Pacifiers Bad?

When asked if pacifiers are bad, the common answer is no; pacifiers are not inherently bad. 

They can provide comfort and help soothe babies. However, prolonged and excessive pacifier use can potentially lead to dental issues.

It’s important to use pacifiers in moderation and follow recommended safe and appropriate usage guidelines.

What to Do When Your Baby Does Not Want to Take the Pacifier?

If your baby won’t take the pacifier, respecting their preferences is important. Every baby is different, and not all babies will be interested in using a pacifier. 

Instead of forcing the pacifier, try other soothing techniques such as cuddling, rocking, or offering a clean finger for sucking. 

Remember, not all babies need or enjoy pacifiers, and it’s perfectly normal if your baby doesn’t want to use one.

Final Verdict

Final Verdict

After carefully considering various pacifiers’ features, pros, and cons, it’s time for the final verdict. Here are my choices for budget, premium, and my personal favorite.

Budget Choice – Combi Teteo Pacifier Smile

The Combi Teteo Pacifier Smile is my best budget choice due to its affordable price point without compromising quality and features. 

It offers a contoured shape, a soft nipple, and a design that promotes proper oral development, making it an excellent value-for-money option for parents.

Premium Choice – Philips Avent 6-18m Ultra Air Baby Pacifier

The Philips Avent 6-18m Ultra Air Baby Pacifier is my best premium choice. Its exceptional quality, innovative design, and attention to detail make it worth the investment. 

The ultra-air shield allows for maximum airflow, reducing skin irritation, and the orthodontic nipple shape mimics breastfeeding, ensuring a comfortable experience for my little one. 

The durable materials and easy-to-clean design further add to its appeal, making it a top-notch pacifier that delivers both style and functionality.

Editor’s Choice – Dr. Brown’s Pacifier Advantage

Dr. Brown’s Pacifier Advantage is my favorite choice because it offers the perfect blend of comfort and functionality. The symmetrical shape and reversible bulb ensure a proper fit. 

The unique guard design grows with my baby, preventing skin allergies, while the soft silicone material provides a soothing experience. 

It’s a reliable pacifier I can trust to support my breastfeeding journey and keep my little one content.

Conclusion

Finding the best pacifier for your breastfed baby can be a personal and important decision. 

You can make an informed choice by considering factors such as size and shape, materials used, age range suitability, and following the dos and don’ts of pacifier use. 

Remember to prioritize your baby’s comfort, safety, and overall breastfeeding experience. You can provide your little one with soothing support with the right pacifier.

Trust your instincts and enjoy this precious bonding time with your baby.

Nayna Llenos
Nayna Llenos

Hi, I’m Nayna!
I’ve always wanted to be a mother, and I’m lucky and blessed to have two wonderful children to care for and love.
Despite this blessing, there are times wherein I do wonder if I truly am the mother my children need. Am I giving them the right food, care, and discipline to them?
But that is the beauty of parenting — you grow along with your children as they flourish to be their wonderful selves!
I wish to share my experiences with motherhood and how these tips can help you in your parenting journey.
I hope my advices and experiences will prove useful to you and that you have a smooth and wonderful journey as a mother!