bamama is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

The Best Pacifiers for Fussy Babies: The Top Picks [2023]

The Best Pacifiers for Fussy Babies The Top Picks [2023]

For any parent, a pacifier can be a lifesaver!

If you have a fussy and crying baby and have tried various methods without success, using a pacifier can help calm the situation.

This article will discuss some of the best pacifiers I was fortunate enough to buy for my baby. From newborns to teething babies, we will explore different pacifiers that prioritize safety, durability, and functionality. 

Get ready as we will discuss 5 of the best pacifiers today that will transform those fussy moments into soft, calm, and contented babies that will lighten your day!

EDITOR’S CHOICE

Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier

PREMIUM CHOICE

Philips Avent Glow in the Dark Ultra Air Night Time Pacifier

BUDGET CHOICE

Dr. Brown’s Prevent Orthodontic Pacifier Newborn Soother

What Are the 5 Best Pacifiers You Can Get in the Market?

Choosing the best pacifier for your baby can be difficult, so I have compiled the 5 best pacifiers. 

This list will help you choose the best pacifier for your breastfed baby, as these pacifiers I’ve listed were great based on my experience. 

1. Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier – Editor’s Choice

Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier

Features:

  • Materials: Silicone. (BPA-Free and Latex-Free)
  • Age Recommendation: 0 to 6 Months
  • Nipple Design: Orthodontic

The Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier is a tested and proven product known to soothe newborn babies. 

In my opinion, the best feature of this pacifier is its round-shaped design and wide base that closely resembles a mother’s nipple. This design helps keep your newborn’s tongue in a stable position due to the straight nipple shape.

In addition, this pacifier is made of hospital-grade, BPA-free silicone materials

It is one of the reasons why hospitals from around the world use this particular pacifier for newborn patients. 

The friendly orthodontic nipple allows your newborn to suck it with ease, and the design should leave no worries behind as it ensures your baby’s natural development of their teeth. 

What I also love about this pacifier is how well it soothes my baby. Everything went peacefully from the moment I used this pacifier for my newborn. 

I didn’t encounter any issues, and my little one is always fast asleep and doesn’t feel any fussiness since it was introduced. 

PROS

  • Easy to clean and washable 
  • Recommended by doctors and hospitals
  • Always available in different colors
  • Feels very durable and easy to latch on
  • Safe to use for up to 6 months

CONS

  • Lighter colors tend to lose them quickly
  • High price

2. Philips Avent Glow in the Dark Ultra Air Night Time Pacifier- Premium Choice

Philips Avent Glow in the Dark Ultra Air Night Time Pacifier

Features:

  • Materials: Silicone. (BPA-Free and Latex-Free)
  • Age Recommendation: 0 to 6 Months, 6 to 18 months
  • Nipple Design: Standard

The Philips Avent Glow in the Dark Ultra Air Night Time Pacifier is another exceptional product from Philips Avent and my premium choice for various reasons

One notable feature of this pacifier is its glow-in-the-dark capability, which makes it easy to find even in the dark when my newborn is sound asleep.

Its Ultra Air feature also helps keep our baby’s skin dry and allows for better airflow. The nipple easily latches onto my baby’s mouth, and it was quickly accepted, even when introduced on short notice.

The design of the nipple is very straightforward. I have been a fan of Philips Avent products for a long time, and the BPA-free features make this pacifier safe for my baby too. 

It also meets the EN1400 Standard for added safety and peace of mind when it comes to our newborn’s well-being. If you prioritize your baby’s safety and are willing to invest, this pacifier is a great choice.

It’s great for a baby’s delicate skin and allows natural teeth development and tongue motion when breastfeeding. 

PROS

  • Glow-in-the-dark
  • Complies with EN1400 standard.
  • Durable, soft, and lightweight
  • BPA-free

CONS

  • High price

3. Dr. Brown’s Prevent Orthodontic Pacifier Newborn Soother – Budget Choice

Dr. Brown’s Prevent Orthodontic Pacifier Newborn Soother

Features:

  • Materials: Silicone. (BPA-Free and Latex-Free)
  • Age Recommendation: 0 to 6 Months
  • Nipple Design: Orthodontic

Dr. Brown’s has been one of the most reputable and reliable brands for baby products, and their own Orthodontic Pacifier is another amazing pacifier designed for newborns. 

This is a great product because it has the same shape as most Dr. Brown baby bottles, making it easier for your newborn to adjust to.

In addition, this pacifier is made of silicone materials, ensuring it will be durable and free from all the unwanted harsh chemicals commonly found in plastics.

It features air channels that minimize pressure while your newborn is sucking, allowing for a more comfortable experience. These suction-free channels help spread air and reduce pressure for maximum comfort.

This pacifier is a fantastic choice for parents with newborns, especially if you already use Dr. Brown’s baby bottles. It offers excellent value for money, combining the features you need in a pacifier.

PROS

  • Minimal and lightweight design
  • Air channels reduce pressure when sucking
  • Easy transition when using Dr. Brown’s baby bottles
  • Safe and durable
  • Spreads air for maximum comfort

CONS

  • It can be lost easily

4. MAM Baby Pacifier Newborn Orthodontic Soother With Silicone Teat and Sterilizer

MAM Baby Pacifier Newborn Orthodontic Soother With Silicone Teat and Sterilizer

Features:

  • Materials: Silicone. (BPA-Free and BPS-Free)
  • Age Recommendation: 0 to 6 Months
  • Nipple Design: Orthodontic

This pacifier from MAM is lightweight, durable, and extra small, making it one of the best pacifiers for newborns up to 6 months. The butterfly-shaped design leaves plenty of space for your newborn’s nose and chin.

Furthermore, the bigger holes around the pacifier reduce the saliva, mucus, or sweat buildup that may irritate your baby’s delicate skin. 

It doesn’t fall off easily, and its symmetrical nipple design allows it to be accepted by babies.

In addition, this pacifier boasts an impressive 94% acceptance rate, making it highly likely that your baby will embrace it, saving you time and money on trying multiple options.

It also comes with a self-sterilizing box that makes the pacifier easy to clean in as short as 3 mins and up to 48 hours! Overall, I am satisfied with how this pacifier works!

When I introduced this pacifier to my newborn, I didn’t experience the issues that bothered me with other options.

My baby is extremely happy with its performance and straightforward design. 

PROS

  • It comes with a self-sterilizing box
  • Curved shield for added comfort
  • 94% acceptance rate 
  • Easy to clean and dishwasher safe
  • Fits perfectly

CONS

  • Too small

5. Tommee Tippee 0-6M Breast Like Baby Pacifier

Tommee Tippee 0-6M Breast Like Baby Pacifier

Features:

  • Materials: Silicone. (BPA-Free and BPS-Free)
  • Age Recommendation: 0 to 6 Months
  • Nipple Design: Orthodontic

Tommee and Tippee is one of the most popular brands regarding baby products. Like most pacifiers I have bought for my baby, their baby pacifier allowed for easy transition due to its nipple design. 

Similar to Dr. Brown’s Pacifier, the Tommee Tippee pacifiers are designed similarly to Tommee Tippee baby bottles, making the transition easy and smooth.

This pacifier stands out from the rest with its glow-in-the-dark design, allowing me to easily spot it even in the dark. I particularly appreciate this feature as it helps me quickly locate the pacifier when it falls on the floor.

Another feature I liked is its flexibility and stretchability, which I believe helps provide a soothing experience for my baby. 

I have experienced some hard nipples, and they weren’t giving me a pleasant time, resulting in a fussy baby. However, I didn’t have those problems with this product.

The super soft silicone materials and flexibility gave my baby a wonderful time. The teat design resembles an actual mother’s nipple, and the glow-in-the-dark design makes it easy to see it when the lights are off. 

PROS

  • Glow-in-the-dark
  • Made from super soft silicone for a natural feel
  • Easy to handle for babies and parents
  • Curved away from baby’s face for added comfort
  • Easy transition from pacifier to baby bottle

CONS

  • The glow doesn’t last long enough

How to Find a Great Pacifier for Your Baby

How to Find a Great Pacifier for Your Baby

Choosing the RIGHT PACIFIER can be challenging, so considering a few factors when buying a pacifier can help you sort out things and pick the right one for your baby. 

Before you shop online or head out to your local store,, here are some things you need to consider. 

Materials

Most pacifiers available today are made of safe and durable materials such as silicone, natural rubber, or latex. These materials provide soothing comfort for your baby’s gums and support natural teeth development.

Natural rubber is an affordable and durable choice that does not contain harmful plastic chemicals. However, it is less flexible compared to silicone and latex materials.

Some newborns are also allergic to latex, so it would be better to try things off before settling for a new one.

Additionally, it’s recommended to choose pacifiers with one-piece designs as they are easy to store and reduce the risk of choking. Avoid pacifiers that require assembly, as they can pose a choking hazard.

Lastly, opt for pacifiers that are dishwasher-safe, as they can be conveniently cleaned to minimize bacterial growth.

Design

Simpler pacifier designs are highly recommended to avoid any complications. Look for pacifiers that are built in one piece and avoid those with attachments, as they can pose choking hazards for newborns.

Additionally, make sure the pacifier doesn’t fit entirely into your baby’s mouth, as this can pose a safety risk. Choosing a design that maximizes air or has air holes for added ventilation is also recommended. 

Nipple Shape

When it comes to nipple shape, there are three popular options to choose from: standard-shaped pacifiers, orthodontic pacifiers, and cherry nipples.

Standard-shaped pacifiers are the most common type, resembling actual nipples. They have long, cylindrical shapes that are straightforward in design.

Orthodontic pacifiers are designed similarly to standard ones. However, they have a natural-looking nipple design but are slightly flatter and square. The design is intended to simulate a newborn’s natural tongue motion when nursing. 

Cherry nipples are like bulb-shaped designs. Nevertheless, pediatricians suggest finding the right nipple shape for your baby.

it’s important to note that there is no one perfect nipple shape for all babies. However, experts suggest choosing a nipple shape that allows your newborn to latch onto it longer and use their tongue, like when breastfeeding. 

Wide-base pacifiers are great because they mimic how the baby’s lips and tongue move during pacifier sucking. On the other hand, straight nipples are more likely to keep a newborn’s tongue moving naturally, similar to when they are breastfeeding.

Each pacifier design is unique. The pacifier your newborn will prefer depends on their individual preference. It’s recommended to try out a few different designs to find the one that works best for your baby.

Size

Pacifiers are not one-size-fits-all baby products. These products are designed specifically to prevent choking hazards.

It’s important to choose the right size for your baby, and age recommendations are typically provided for each pacifier. There are two sizes available: 0-6 months and 6-18 months.

Make sure to select a pacifier that matches your child’s age to ensure a proper fit and safety.

Pacifier Do’s and Don’ts

Pacifier Do's and Don'ts

When it comes to shopping for and using a pacifier for your baby, there are some important do’s and don’ts to keep in mind.

Do’s

  • Use one-piece pacifiers to avoid choking hazards.
  • Keep them clean all the time to avoid bacterial growth. As much as possible, look for pacifiers that are also dishwasher-friendly, as they need to be washed more frequently.
  • Replace pacifiers that are already broken and worn out.
  • Make sure the pacifier you use is appropriate for your baby’s age.
  • Have a backup pacifier ready; they can easily get lost inside the room or house. 
  • Learn the appropriate time when to introduce a pacifier to your baby.

Don’ts

  • Never force your newborn to use a pacifier. If you notice that the pacifier frequently falls out of your baby’s mouth, it may not be the right match for them. Simply putting it back in won’t solve the problem. It can either be they don’t want the design or don’t like pacifiers at all. 
  • Never put something on the pacifier to encourage your newborn to use it. It is NOT recommended to put honey or puree on the nipple of a pacifier to entice a newborn to use it, which is what some parents do.
  • Never put attachments to your baby’s pacifier, as this can be extremely dangerous. Putting attachments like a cord or a ribbon are choking hazards.
  • The pacifier is not the end-all-be-all solution to a crying baby. I suggest trying other methods first, including rocking, holding, or singing. The pacifier should be the last option for a fussy baby. 

Furthermore, the American Academy of Family Physicians and the American Academy of Pediatrics recommend gradually reducing pacifier use for babies during the second 6 months of their life to minimize the risk of middle ear infections.

On the other hand, the American Dental Association strongly advises discontinuing pacifier use by the age of 4. This recommendation minimizes the risk of tongue and mouth issues and promotes natural development of the mouth.

The good news is that many kids and toddlers naturally stop using pacifiers between the ages of 2 and 4.

However, if your children haven’t stopped the habit yet, one helpful approach is to praise them whenever they are not using a pacifier. This positive reinforcement can encourage them to gradually let go of the pacifier.

Nevertheless, always ask for a doctor’s help if you have concerns about your kid’s pacifier use. 

What’s the Best Pacifier for Newborns?

Pacifiers come in different sizes, shapes, and features. There is no superior pacifier compared to others.

However, it is important to choose one that is suitable for your baby’s age. As your baby grows, ensure that the pacifiers they use are slightly larger than the previous ones to prevent choking incidents.

The ideal pacifier should effectively soothe a fussy baby while promoting natural mouth development without any complications.

Lastly, NEVER FORCE your baby to use a particular pacifier if they consistently spit it out. Every baby is different, so it may be necessary to try different options to find the one that suits them best.

How to Introduce Your Baby to Pacifiers

How to Introduce Your Baby to Pacifiers

Health professionals say the best time to introduce a pacifier to your baby is around 3 to 4 weeks after birth. 

Always remember that each baby has their own preferences.

We’re trying to say that what works for one baby might not work for the other, so be sure to try a few to get the right one for them.

If you are a first-time parent, introducing them to a pacifier is slightly more straightforward than one parent may think. 

Try these steps when helping your newborn discover the use of a pacifier during the early stages of their lives. 

  • Before introducing a pacifier, it is important to ensure that it is thoroughly cleaned. Even if it is a new pacifier, I recommend washing it to remove any potential dust buildup.
  • To start, gently touch the skin and lip of your baby with the tip of the teat of the pacifier. This way, you activate your baby’s rooting reflex, leading them to turn to that stimulus.
  • Observe your baby’s behavior. If you notice that your newborn is opening their mouth, it may indicate that they are searching for something to suckle. In that case, gently place the pacifier on their lower lip and wait for their reaction to see if they will suckle on it.
  • If the first try is successful, your baby will eventually discover the pacifier and begin to suckle on it.

Based on my experience, do not force your baby to suckle the pacifier. If the first try didn’t go as planned, try again the other day or a few hours later. 

Forcing them to suckle it might result in a negative response, making it harder to introduce them to it. 

If your baby rejects the pacifier, this might be a telltale sign that they need a little bit more time to explore and discover the use of a pacifier. If this happens, introducing the pacifier a week or two after would be ideal. 

Give your newborn plenty of time to discover themselves. Don’t force or rush things; it will fall into place. 

Babies can be unpredictable when it comes to their preferences, so while they may not like the pacifier one day, they might learn to love it the next day.

If you’re a first-time parent, it can be a bit challenging to navigate pacifier use, but take it slowly and steadily. Soon enough, you’ll find yourself enjoying a good night’s rest as the pacifier effectively soothes your fussing baby to sleep.

Introducing new things to your baby is a learning experience, and it’s natural for them to explore and discover through their senses.

Don’t worry too much, as your baby will gradually figure out how to use a pacifier with your guidance. You’ll be there to support them along the way and assist in any way you can.

Pacifier Benefits

While it can be tempting to soothe a crying baby by offering a pacifier, it’s important to note that it may NOT always be the best solution.

It is also worth noting that a baby experiencing extreme fussiness could indicate an underlying medical condition, which your pediatrician should determine. However, using a pacifier also has the following benefits:

  • Studies have shown that using a pacifier while sleeping reduces the risk of sudden infant death syndrome. 
  • A pacifier can help put your baby to sleep.
  • A pacifier can serve as a distraction for any fussy baby.
  • During teething, a pacifier can serve as a suitable alternative to a teether. To provide relief to your baby’s sore gums, you can cool the pacifier in the refrigerator before offering it to them. The cold temperature can help soothe their discomfort.
  • If you frequently travel by airplane with your family, having a pacifier on hand can be beneficial. It can help alleviate discomfort during flights, especially when the air pressure changes. Encouraging your newborn to suck on a pacifier during takeoff and landing can help equalize the pressure in their ears and provide relief.
  • Pacifiers are disposable, so you can just throw them away when your baby no longer needs them or if they become worn out.
  • You can also include them in your hospital diaper bag if you welcome another baby. 

Pacifier Drawbacks 

When there are benefits, there are also drawbacks to using a pacifier on your newborn.

  • Using a pacifier for your baby might lead to pacifier dependence. When your newborn relies on a pacifier to sleep, if it falls off during the night, you may need to wake up to soothe them as they may start crying.
  • Pacifiers might increase the risk of middle ear infections. 
  • Prolonged pacifier use might lead to dental problems and can lead to your baby’s teeth being misaligned.
  • Pacifier use might disrupt breastfeeding. When introducing a pacifier, you might want to hold it down for a few weeks after your baby is born. You can introduce it once you’ve settled into a nursing routine.
  • Nipple confusion can occur when formula feeding your baby, causing a mix-up in nipple preference. To minimize this, it’s recommended to use the same type of nipple as your baby bottles.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

You might find some answers below if you have some additional questions. 

Can Teething Babies Use Pacifiers?

Pacifiers are soothing essentials needed by babies. The great thing about them is that they can be cooled to provide soothing relief for teething babies.

To soothe effectively, store the pacifier inside the refrigerator and allow it to cool for more than 30 minutes. This coolness helps numb your teething baby’s gums, offering immediate relief. You can also do the same thing for teethers.

When Should I Introduce My Baby to Pacifiers?

When babies are born, they have a natural sucking reflex that is crucial for feeding and can also provide comfort to newborns.

The optimal time to introduce a pacifier to your newborn is typically around 3 to 4 weeks after birth. This allows them to establish a nursing routine before introducing additional sucking patterns.

It’s always a good idea to consult with your pediatrician for personalized guidance.

Should I Remove My Baby’s Pacifier Once They Are Asleep?

If you’ve ever wondered whether you should remove the pacifier when your baby is sleeping, there’s no need to worry!

If you remove the pacifier while your baby is sleeping, there’s a big chance they might wake up and become fussy again.

According to AAP or the American Academy of Pediatrics, a pacifier can offer protection against SIDS, even if it has already fallen off your newborn’s mouth. 

Do Pacifiers Help with Gas?

Unfortunately, there is no scientific study showing that pacifiers can specifically help with gas. However, pacifiers can serve multiple purposes, such as soothing a fussy baby and providing comfort to many infants.

Furthermore, using a pacifier that is not the appropriate size for your newborn can lead to them swallowing air, which may cause discomfort and fussiness. It is important to ensure that the pacifier is the right fit for your baby to avoid such issues.

As mentioned earlier, it is crucial to always choose a pacifier that is specifically designed for your baby’s age.

How Long Should a Newborn Use a Pacifier?

Your newborn can use a pacifier until they reach 3 years old, but there are situations where it may need to be discontinued.

If the pacifier starts to interfere with their feeding or eating habits, it’s important to switch to a pacifier that is suitable for their age or consider not using one at all.

Using a pacifier beyond the age of 3 can potentially cause misalignment of the teeth and contribute to speech issues, as highlighted by health experts.

It is advisable to adhere to the age recommendations for pacifier usage to ensure the safety and well-being of your child.

Can My Baby Use a Regular Pacifier?

There are specific pacifiers designed for newborns and others intended for babies aged 6 months and older. Using a pacifier that is not appropriate for your baby’s age can pose a choking hazard.

Similarly, older babies should not use pacifiers intended for newborns, as they can fit entirely into their mouths and increase the risk of choking.

Parents should always follow the age recommendation for the pacifier they are using. 

Summary

Summary

Here is a summary of my top picks to help you pick and choose the right pacifier for your newborn. 

Budget Choice – Dr. Brown’s Prevent Orthodontic Pacifier

If you are already using Dr. Brown’s baby bottles, their Orthodontic pacifier is a great choice as it is designed to complement the bottles and facilitate a smooth transition for your baby.

The pacifier and bottles work together to support your baby’s ongoing development in the coming months.

The orthodontic design of the pacifier promotes natural teeth development without causing any alterations. The standard nipple shape is designed to mimic a mother’s nipple, allowing your baby to latch onto it comfortably for extended periods of time.

Premium Choice – Philips Avent Ultra Air Pacifier

Despite being introduced to my second newborn, I have quickly grown to love the Philips Avent Ultra Air Pacifier.

This pacifier stands out with its baby-centered design, and one feature I particularly appreciate is its innovative airflow system, which ensures optimal ventilation.

As a result, the Philips Avent Ultra Air Pacifier provides several benefits. The breathable design allows your baby’s sensitive skin to breathe, while the textured and collapsible silicone nipple soothes their gums and teeth.

Additionally, the pacifier promotes the natural development of your baby’s teeth.

Editor’s Choice – Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier

You can always go right with Philips Avent products.

The Philips Avent Ultra Air Pacifiers are specifically designed for newborns, ensuring their safety with tested and proven materials. I was pleasantly surprised by the affordable price, considering all the features it offers.

It’s reassuring to see that this brand prioritizes the well-being of our babies by avoiding harmful materials. The orthodontic nipple provides soothing comfort, and the thoughtful design is tailored to meet our babies’ needs.

Final Verdict

Pacifiers have long been a trusted tool to soothe fussy babies, and it’s undeniable that they offer numerous benefits.

With the wide range of options available in the market, I have tested and proven the 5 best pacifiers for fussy babies based on my own experience.

These products have been a go-to solution for decades, and having one for your baby can make a significant difference in keeping them calm and content. After all, when it comes to pacifiers, there aren’t many alternatives to turn to, right?

This article serves as a guide to the best pacifiers available in the Philippines.

Each product mentioned has its own merits and is designed to provide relief from your baby’s crying and fussiness.

Nayna Llenos
Nayna Llenos

Hi, I’m Nayna!
I’ve always wanted to be a mother, and I’m lucky and blessed to have two wonderful children to care for and love.
Despite this blessing, there are times wherein I do wonder if I truly am the mother my children need. Am I giving them the right food, care, and discipline to them?
But that is the beauty of parenting — you grow along with your children as they flourish to be their wonderful selves!
I wish to share my experiences with motherhood and how these tips can help you in your parenting journey.
I hope my advices and experiences will prove useful to you and that you have a smooth and wonderful journey as a mother!